LDS Seminary

Hmmmm… I haven’t seen anything that says “I love Seminary” before — it would be pretty unusual to find something like that since most LDS product manufacturers are out of Utah, and they cater to the Utah Mormon population where Seminary teacher is a paid full-time professional teaching position, and it’s extremely unlikely those teachers would be buying gifts for their 150+ students.

You could try these keyring/zipper pulls – they have sayings like “return with honor” and “choose you this day” and “what would Jesus do” on them.

I’m not sure how your keychains look, but could you cut the back off of a tie tack and glue them to your keychains?

Or maybe these link charms would work. There is a link charm keyring down at the bottom of the page that’s pretty cool — the girls in your class would love these, but I’m not sure about the boys.

Sorry I’m not much help! Let me know if you find anything that will work for you!

-j